Entering the United States at the invitation of a Boston institution and speaking excellent English, Bell may not have thought himself an immigrant until his first attempt to patent his telephone was rejected on the grounds that he was an alien. Once naturalized, Bell proudly proclaimed himself an American citizen.
Alexander Graham Bell’s grandfather taught correct pronunciation and elocution, as did Bell’s father, Alexander Melville Bell. Young Bell became adept at teaching “Visible Speech,” the system of symbols his father invented showing the positions of the lips, tongue, and soft palate needed to reproduce all sounds. In May, 1868, Bell used Visible Speech for the first time to teach the deaf to speak English.
Alexander Graham Bell around 1902.
After both of Bell’s brothers died of tuberculosis, his father moved the family to the more healthful climate of Canada, settling at Brantford, Ontario, in August, 1870. When the Boston School for the Deaf invited Bell’s father to teach Visible Speech there, he sent his son instead. There were then no requirements that Bell hold a passport or have a visa to enter the United States, and Bell did not think himself an immigrant in March, 1871, when he traveled forty-five miles east to Buffalo, New York, and casually boarded a through train to Boston.
Bell found the city congenial, teaching at the School for the Deaf, becoming professor of vocal physiology and elocution at Boston University, and privately tutoring deaf students, including Mabel Hubbard, who later became his wife. He experimented at night, seeking a way to transmit speech over an electric wire. Bell was rudely awakened to his alien status when he tried to file a caveat (notice of intention to file a patent) with the United States Patent Office to establish priority as the inventor of the telephone. Told that, although aliens were eligible to apply for patents, only citizens could file caveats, Bell began the process of naturalization. He took out his first papers in 1874, which granted him most rights of citizens, except the right to vote. He did not complete the process and become a full citizen until November 10, 1882, by which time he had patented the telephone (1876) and moved to Washington, D.C., where he still could not vote in presidential elections.
Bell and his wife honeymooned in Great Britain, where his wife became pregnant and gave birth to their first daughter. Her birth there made the daughter technically a dual British American citizen, as was her father; British law counted all born in Britain as subjects of Queen Victoria for life. Because wives assumed the status of husbands under both British and American law, the entire family could have, but did not, consider themselves dual nationals.
Bell was proud of his American citizenship, specifically rejecting in 1915 the notion that he was a hyphenated American and flying the
Bruce, Robert V. Bell: Alexander Graham Bell and the Conquest of Solitude. Boston: Little, Brown, 1973. Grosvenor, Edwin S., and Morgan Wesson. Alexander Graham Bell: The Life and Times of the Man Who Invented the Telephone. New York: Harry N. Abrams, 1997. Shulman, Seth. The Telephone Gambit: Chasing Alexander Graham Bell’s Secret. New York: W. W. Norton, 2008.
Canada vs. United States as immigrant destinations